Wednesday, 11 July 2012

A Tale of Two Halves

This afternoon South Eastern was hit by two lightning strikes which put out the signalling on each side of Sevenoaks.   These things do happen (though the signalling appears to be remarkably vulnerable to this occurrence) and, having noticed the delays starting to build up I left the office early to catch the 1549 from London Bridge.



There were clearly already problems because this service was to be started from London Bridge, the inbound service clearly having arrived too late to go up to Charing Cross and back.   This isn’t too much of an inconvenience if you know about it – though not if you turn up at Charing Cross only two or three minutes before departure.



In this case it wouldn’t really have mattered because we were 5 minutes late leaving London Bridge, in any case but I was prepared to be up to 30 minutes late and so it turned out.



The conductor on the train was excellent, keeping everybody informed about progress and making it clear where he had no information and where he was just relaying what he had been told.   After we left Tonbridge, by this time 35 minutes late, he even ensured the catering trolley offered everyone free drinks (though there wasn’t ,much left by the time they got down to me).



So far, so good, and I was prepared to write a very complimentary piece about South Eastern as a result.   However, Ashford control then stepped in.   Readers of previous entries will know that Ashford control has a tendency to make off the cuff decisions which normally involve people having to get off trains for no obvious significant benefits to anyone except themselves.



As we sat in Ashford station there came an announcement saying that the train would now run fast to Canterbury West, instead of stopping at Wye, Chilham and Chartham.   This would save about 5 minutes, I estimated.



And when was the next train to Chilham?   Another 35 minutes as that train was running even later than the one I was on, making me 70 minutes late home.   And could they stop the high speed?   No they couldn’t.   I even rang the customer service desk to see if they could be persuaded to stop the high-speed at Chilham, but, after suggesting that I wrote in a letter to ask for it, they just hung up.



There were about 15 people travelling to the local stations who were already 35 minutes late at Ashford and now had to wait an additional 35 minutes.   Admittedly more were travelling through to Canterbury and Ramsgate, but this move saved them only 5 minutes when they were already 35 minutes late.   It was an absurd decision but of a piece with Ashford control’s usual standards.



A more cynical explanation is that they thought that if they ran fast from Ashford to Canterbury they could just get down to under 30 minutes late and so would not have to pay delay-repay.   Admittedly they would end up paying twice as much to the people wanting to go to the local stations, but there are fewer of them.



Needless to say this disruption did not feature on SouthEastern’s twitter feed or on their website – which merely recorded ‘minor disruption’ on the Ashford line.



There is a huge tendency on South Eastern to try and minimise any disruption, either by not reporting it or by reporting it as smaller than it actually is.  Hence large scale delays of 30 minutes or more are ‘minor disruptions’, many delays and cancellations are not shown in the ‘live information’ and the forecast length of delay is minimised.   So, at Ashford, waiting for 35 minutes, the train was initially reported as 18 minutes late, then 25 minutes late and then 28 minutes late, when looking at its progress it was clear it was 35 minutes late all the time.   Such deceit helps no-one and only leads to regular travellers just not trusting anything that South Eastern says.⨪

No comments:

Post a Comment